Blogging the Social Studies Debate II

12:18 p.m. – Civil rights groups are out in force today, with speakers calling on the Texas State Board of Education to stop undermining the coverage of minorities and the civil rights movement in the standards.

12:32 – State Rep. Mike Villarreal, D-San Antonio, noted the state board debate on his Web site this morning:

“I hope the SBOE does the right thing, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they show up on one of the Comedy Central Shows this week.”

Neither would we, Rep. Villarreal.

12:46 – State troopers have been posted outside the board room. That’s unusual. Are board members worried about the civil rights supporters here to speak today?

1:03 – Now someone is criticizing “atheists” and “statists” for corrupting the education of young people. Statists are promoting “class warfare,” he charges, and “minority victimization.”

2:08 – The board is gathering after a lunch break. Board members will continue hearing public testimony for a while longer this afternoon.

2:11 – Steven Schafersman of Texas Citizens for Science is also blogging from today’s board meeting.

2:15 – One testifier goes after board member Don McLeroy’s contention that minorities owe thanks to the majority for gaining equal rights in this country. Click here to hear what McLeroy had to say on the subject in September. The speaker is also critical of other efforts by far-right board members to rewrite the history of the civil rights movement with political nonsense. McLeroy offers no challenge to the testimony.

2:35 – Another testifier worries aloud about efforts to remove information about America’s “Judeo-Christian” heritage. Yet no one has suggested that students shouldn’t learn about the influence of religion in American history. TFN certainly has not done so. The issue is whether students will learn the falsehood that the Founders intended to create a Christian nation based on fundamentalist Christian principles. The Founders did not, but some board members — such as Don McLeroy, Cynthia Dunbar and Terri Leo — are determined to rewrite American history to advance their ideological point of view in public school classrooms.

2:44 – Luis Figueroa of the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund (MALDEF) calls on the board to stop efforts to rewrite and water down instruction on the history of the civil rights movement.

3:16 – A testifier calls on the state board to make sure “students are educated on the facts.” She then goes on a long diatribe against Islam and threats posed by Muslims, particularly through population growth: “Europe could be lost to Islam without a shot being fired.” She says students should learn that the Muslims are taught to kill non-Muslims after the holy month of Ramadan. And on it goes…

3:30 – A conservative testifier asks that the standard calling on students to study the significance of the 2008 election (the election of an African-American president) should also be required to study the supposed “backlash” from Americans in 2009-10. Board member Ken Mercer suggests that perhaps students should learn about the Tea Party movement.

3:47 – Board conservatives are disputing why Dolores Huerta was removed from the Grade 3 standards in January. She was removed because board members said she is a socialist. Board member Ken Mercer suggests that Huerta is NOT a good role model for young students because she’s a socialist. One wonders if Mr. Mercer knows much at all about the cofounder of the United Farm Workers of America.

4:34 – The board apparently will finish testimony from everyone signed up to speak. It could be another hour or more before board debate begins.

4:41 – Jonathan Saenz of the far-right group Liberty Institute (formerly Free Market Foundation) is up. Liberty Institute (the Texas affiliate of Focus on the Family) has been one of the primary groups promoting the lie that curriculum writers don’t want students to learn about Christmas, American heroes and patriotic symbols. And now he’s going on again about protecting “Judeo-Christian values” in the standards. Saenz charges that the board has been under “pressure” to downplay the subject of Christianity in the standards. That’s another lie. Saenz should be ashamed of himself. He and his organization have spent months now attacking the faith and patriotism of teachers and other curriculum writers, yet he claims that unnamed people are attacking Christianity.

5:19 – Ken Mercer argues essentially that the presence of Congressional chaplains, prayers in Congressional sessions, and “In God We Trust” means the United States is a Christian nation.

5:31 – A testifier wants students to learn that LBJ and the CIA had President Kennedy assassinated in 1963. The train has officially pulled into Crazy Town.

6:02 – The board is finally ready to begin debate over the standards.

This article was posted in these categories: live blog. Bookmark the permalink. Follow comments with the RSS feed for this post. Post a Comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


-->

6 Comments

  1. Jason
    Posted March 13, 2010 at 12:56 am | Permalink

    sinz54 subscribes to a lot of lies and tripe as well.

    Our Cold War opponent subscribed to a variant of Marxism (which is why the USSR always described its system as “Marxist-Leninist.” Marx’s theory argued that a society *had* to go through capitalism before going to socialism. It was Lenin who theorized that a small “vanguard party” could allow a barely industrial society like Tsarist Russia to skip over capitalism and go straight to socialism).

    Other Marxists denounced the USSR as a “degenerated workers state” (Trotsky) or “bureaucratic collectivism” (Max Shachtman).

    The Democratic Socialists of America (like other democratic socialists) criticized the Soviet Union for its lack of political freedom.

    The anarchists called themselves socialists, but denounced Marxism as naturally leading to a new authority. (see in particular Bakunin’s hostility toward Marx’s works).

    The “Eurocommunists” of the 1970s broke away from Soviet orthodoxy on the grounds that it wasn’t relevant to Western European societies. And the Democratic Socialists of America also were sharply critical of the Soviet Union.

    “Socialism” is not interchangeable with “Marxism,” any more than “republic” is with “democracy.”

  2. Steve Masy
    Posted March 13, 2010 at 12:32 am | Permalink

    You know who else kids shouldn’t learn about? Helen Keller. Hardcore socialist. And Eugene V. Debs. Big time socialist who won a good chunk of votes. Ignore him too.

    And, Sinz, you also believe that students should be educated about the lies, fallacies, and inadequacies of capitalism (or ‘the free enterprise system’), correct? No double standards now.

    And, of course, anyone that equates Marxism with socialism has no idea about either one and is playing the fool. I’m not sure the Swedes, Danes, Norse, French, Israelis, or English would call themselves Marxist. They might, however, use the term socialist.

  3. sinz54
    Posted March 12, 2010 at 4:04 pm | Permalink

    Ken Mercer is correct.

    Dolores Huerta is a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, a far-left group that still advocates government control of the means of production and distribution. And it would shock many Americans to find out how many other prominent Americans are members of the DSA and subscribe to their Marxist tripe.

    At a time when the word “socialist” is bandied about so loosely, the DSA–and its members–really are genuine, true socialists. And Huerta is one of them.

    I would have no problem mentioning Huerta–just so long as students are also told that she is a socialist and that they are educated about the lies, fallacies, and inadequacies of socialism, as I was when I went to school during the Cold War.

    We didn’t wage a 50 year long Cold War to start whitewashing Marxism now.

  4. James F
    Posted March 10, 2010 at 7:18 pm | Permalink

    A testifier wants students to learn that LBJ and the CIA had President Kennedy assassinated in 1963. The train has officially pulled into Crazy Town.

    As long as they also learn about The Pentaverate.

  5. Alyssa
    Posted March 10, 2010 at 6:52 pm | Permalink

    Where are these people coming from. Where are the people who are going to fight for the real issues!

  6. Jim Davis
    Posted March 10, 2010 at 5:49 pm | Permalink

    It is interesting that Ken Mercer equates the rise of the Tea Party movement with the election of our first African-American president. I thought it all about taxes and the size of government!

Post a Comment

TFN Insider Comments Policy

Your email is kept private. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>